Sladen Snippet - Proposed “aggregate scheme” amendments to the debt-equity tax rules

On 10 October 2016, the Federal Government released an Exposure Draft to implement changes to the debt and equity tax rules in Division 974 of Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The Exposure Draft is intended to effect recommendations made by the Board of Taxation in its April 2015 report Review of the Debt and Equity Tax Rules.

Division 974 aims to classify interests under financing schemes as either “debt” or “equity” and ensure that the appropriate taxation treatment is applied to a taxpayer’s entitlement to deductibility and franking credits and that a taxpayer does not achieve a tax outcome different to the economic substance of the financing scheme. 

The Exposure Draft proposes to amend Division 974 by including new integrity rules to prevent taxpayers from artificially splitting a single scheme into multiple schemes in order to achieve a favourable tax outcome. 

Currently, s 974-155(1) allows for two or more schemes that are ‘related to one another in any way’ to be treated as related schemes that when combined, could give rise to either a debt or equity interest, with s 970-80 providing an “equity override” integrity provision. The application of the latter provision has been uncertain and contentious in complex financing schemes. Consistent with the Board of Taxation’s recommendations to address this uncertainty, the Exposure Draft proposes to repeal these provisions and insert new aggregation rules.

The new rules are aimed at ensuring that multiple schemes are treated as an “aggregate scheme” where this accurately reflects the economic substance of the scheme, with consideration being given to the following factors (under proposed new s 974-155(1)):                       

  1. whether the pricing, terms and conditions of the schemes are linked in a way that would  change their classification and tax treatment under Division 974; and 
  2. having regard to the following, whether it would be concluded that the schemes were  designed to operate together to produce their combined economic effect:
  • “(i)  the nature and extent of any involvement by the parties to one of the schemes in any of the other schemes;
  • (ii)  the way the schemes are entered into or carried out;
  • (iii)  any dealing, between any of the parties to any of the schemes, that is not at arm’s length;
  • (iv)  the relationships between any of the parties to any of the schemes;
  • (v)  normal commercial understandings and practices;
  • (vi)  any other relevant matters.”

The closing date for submissions on the draft legislation is Monday, 21 November 2016.

To discuss this further or for more information please contact:

Renuka Somers
Special Counsel
Sladen Legal
M +61 407 478 592|  T +61 3 9611 0110

Daniel Smedley
Principal | Accredited Specialist in Tax Law
Sladen Legal
M +61 411 319 327|  T +61 3 9611 0105

Patricia Martins
Legal Executive / Project Manager
Sladen Legal
T +61 3 9611 0138