Sladen Thoughts

Stay up to date with Legal Industry news and updates. Sladen Legal provide regular updates on changes and news in the Australian Legal Industry.

If you are looking for our papers and journal articles including Taxation in Australia, The Tax Institute and SMSF Association, these are available in our Sladen Smart Membership Platform, become a member or login to gain exclusive access.

Sladen Snippet, Superannuation Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Superannuation Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet – Draft legislation released for look through approach for LRBAs

Treasury has released a draft bill to enact a “look through” approach to apply to limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBAs) for income tax and capital gains tax (CGT) purposes, with effect from 1 July 2007. Under a LRBA the asset must be held by the trustee of a separate trust (referred to below as a bare trustee). This has raised a number of issues in relation to how the tax laws interact with the holding of the asset, the super fund and the bare trustee.

Read More
Superannuation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Superannuation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Do recent Court decisions point towards leniency in the new SMSF penalty regime?

Two Federal Court decisions from 2014, DCT v Lyons and DCT v Graham Family Superannuation Pty Ltd have demonstrated the Court’s relatively lenient approach to applying penalties under the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (SIS Act) for cases involving multiple numbers of very serious breaches.

Read More
Superannuation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Superannuation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Related party LRBA loans must be benchmarked

Further to the recent Australian Taxation Office (ATO) release of two ATO Interpretative Decisions, ATO ID 2014/39 and ATO ID 2014/40, as outlined in a recent Sladen Snippet, the ATO has released further information on what factors will be considered when applying the non-arm’s length income (NALI) rules to non-commercial limited recourse borrowing arrangements (LRBAs).

Read More
Commercial Disputes, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Commercial Disputes, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Coronial finding into drowning of school boy


On 27 October 2014 the Coroner’s Court of Victoria delivered its finding into the inquest on the death of Kyle Vassil.  The deceased was a 12 year old student who, on day one of a school camp, drowned in a dam a few meters from shore. Kyle was a competent swimmer who was swimming with other class members in the presence of supervising teachers and young camp leaders when he drowned.  The circumstances surrounding the death were tragic and no doubt traumatic for all persons involved.  The purpose of the Coronial investigation was to ascertain, if possible, the cause of death and the circumstances in which the death occurred.

Read More
Taxation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Taxation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet: Business Restructure Roll-Overs Extended in New Tax Law

The Tax and Superannuation Laws Amendment (2014 Measures No 6) Bill 2014 (the Bill) was introduced to Parliament on 30 October 2014.

Schedule 1 of the Bill seeks to amend the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 to extend the CGT roll-over relief afforded under certain replacement asset roll-overs to revenue assets and trading stock.

Read More
Personal Succession, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Personal Succession, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Changing the way wills can be contested

The Victorian government passed the Justice Legislation Amendment (Succession and Surrogacy) Act 2014  on 16 October, prior to going into caretaker mode leading up to the election.

The Act includes significant amendments to the laws governing the contesting of wills.

Since the removal of any relationship requirement between a claimant and a deceased person in 1996, the courts have dealt with a wide range of claims. These claims are not only by spouses and children of the deceased person, but also grandchildren, nephews and nieces, carers and even neighbours.

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Business Structuring Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Business Structuring Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - ASIC’s expectations for directors

In a recent speech to the Australian Institute of Directors, Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) chairman Greg Medcraft outlined ASIC’s expectations for directors. Previous speeches focused on the director’s role as a gatekeeper, and Mr Medcraft has said this will continue to be a focus for ASIC.

The chairman stated that directors should ensure their company has strong internal and audit compliance functions. He stated these functions are worthless unless the directors back it up with supervision and review, and that these processes are ingrained in the company’s culture. He considered culture a very important point and stressed directors should drive the right compliance culture in the workplace.

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Employment Law Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Employment Law Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Withdrawing a benefit provided under your enterprise agreement may contravene your “no extra claims” clause

A Victorian water authority was found to have contravened the no extra claims clause in its enterprise agreement, in a decision handed down by the Fair Work Commission (FWC) last week. The authority made changes to a vehicle policy which provided some employees with limited private use of work vehicles.  The enterprise agreement itself contained no provisions dealing directly with the provision or private use of motor vehicles.

Read More
Superannuation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Superannuation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen snippet – Recent successes with excess contributions

Sladen Legal had two recent successful applications to disregard or reallocate excess non-concessional contributions, with the result that significant excess contributions assessments were extinguished or reduced to a nominal amount.

In the first case the client inadvertently triggered the bring forward rule by paying what she thought was an insurance premium, but was in fact a contribution to a retail superannuation fund (that in turn funded an insurance policy held by the fund). The client also made a $150K non-concessional contribution in that year followed by a $450K in the following year (causing excess non-concessional contributions of over $150K). The Commissioner of Taxation agreed that special circumstances existed and agreed to reallocate the “insurance” contribution to the second year reducing the excess contributions tax from over $70K to approximately $1,500.

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Commercial Contracts Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Commercial Contracts Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet – Power to correct errors on the PPSR

Justice Gleeson of the Federal Court of Australia has provided further clarification surrounding the power of the Registrar to correct errors on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR) in the case of SFS Projects Australia Pty Ltd v Registrar of Personal Property Securities [2014] FCA 846.

In this case, SFS Projects Australia Pty Ltd (SFS Projects) was assigned three security interests that were already registered on the PPSR. A mistake was made by the assignor who incorrectly changed the end date of the registrations, instead of changing the name of the secured party, to SFS Projects. If the error was not corrected, SFS Projects would be deprived of the benefits of a continuously perfected security interest under the Personal Property Securities Act 2010 (PPSA).

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Property & Development Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Property & Development Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Transfer of Land Amendment Bill 2014 – proposed introduction of priority notices

The Transfer of Land Amendment Bill 2014 (Bill) has been introduced to the Victorian Parliament. The Bill proposes a number of amendments, including provisions to facilitate the phasing out of paper certificates of titles in preparation for the introduction of electronic conveyancing system.

Read More
Taxation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal Taxation, Sladen Snippet Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Transfers of cash and property from private companies in family law settlements

On 30 July 2014 the Australian Taxation Office issued Taxation Ruling TR 2014/5 (previously released in draft form as TR 2013/D6) to address the tax effect of private companies paying money or transferring property to shareholders or their associates, in order to satisfy Family Court orders made pursuant to section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975.

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Superannuation Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Superannuation Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Loan from an SMSF to an unrelated unit trust, not an in-house asset

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has confirmed in ATOID 2014/23 that a loan from a self managed superannuation fund (SMSF) to a unit trust, where the SMSF and its related entities held less than 10% of the units in the unit trust, and did not otherwise ‘control’ the unit trust, will not be treated as an in-house asset.

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Superannuation Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Superannuation Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - ATO confirms adult children can be super dependants

The Australian Taxation Office has confirmed in ATOID 2014/22 that an adult child can be a death benefits dependant under the superannuation laws. In the particular facts of the ATOID, the adult child had given up work to care for a terminally ill parent and received no financial support from anyone, other than the parent, during that time. The child was found to be both financially dependent on, and an interdependent of, the child’s mother. Consequently, any death benefits paid to the adult child would be tax free.

Read More
Sladen Snippet, Commercial Contracts Sladen Legal Sladen Snippet, Commercial Contracts Sladen Legal

Sladen Snippet - Supreme Court grants an injunction against a sham registration on the Personal Property Securities Register

There is no requirement to file the underlying agreement that gives rise to a security interest on the Personal Property Securities Register (Register).  This has the potential to give rise to fake or sham registrations because the Register cannot determine if a registration is in fact a genuine security interest. This creates a situation where the Register can be compromised by the lodgement of sham registrations.

Read More